Against Witchcraft III

Against Witchcraft I

What is more needed than that? 

Although I’ve had a couple people ask me to post the screenshots from the Dionysian Discord here, or to share them with them privately, I am not going to do so for three reasons. 1) It would reveal the identity of my informant. While I did not ask them to spy on this group, wasn’t even aware they were part of the group, and couldn’t care less what a bunch of chronically online halfwits have to say about me, I’m not going to burn someone who’s done me a solid. 2) I didn’t come back to engage in bullshit community politics with a bunch of folks I don’t even consider part of the same religious tradition as mine; I wouldn’t have said anything at all if I hadn’t been so shocked by what was shown me. And 3) there’s no reason to, since almost the exact same things are being said in fully public forums at places like Tumblr and Reddit. For instance here’s a conversation about how the Greek Gods will punish you for holding the wrong political beliefs, or even not affirming the most extreme positions in a party’s platform vehemently enough; and here Zeus and Nemesis are petitioned for the deaths of both Jewish soldiers and civilians (who have no more say in how their government conducts itself than Americans or Brits do) with many of the same individuals participating. If you allow such beliefs and behaviors to go unchallenged that will become the public face of your religion. Be the alternative you want others to see, however you are best suited to do that. If you don’t know what that way is, pray to your Gods and spirits for guidance, inspiration and discernment. It doesn’t have to be eloquent. “O Gods, I am confused. Please help me find understanding, live virtuously, and each day serve as a better instrument of your will in the world.” What is more needed than that? 

setting no one apart

The rest will have to wait until tomorrow evening, but after what I read I wanted to get that last one out. It’s based on the theory that both the Egyptians and Hebrews were enslaved under the Hyksos and that Amalek is the divine progenitor of the Amalekites (a nomadic Hyksos tribe encountered in 1 Samuel and elsewhere) as well as the perpetually reborn spirit of antisemitism. Unlike some folks I won’t try to tell you what Dionysos’ political beliefs are, but I know what Euripides wrote in Bakchai and I believe it:

Will anyone say that I do not respect old age, being about to dance with my head covered in ivy? No, for the God has made no distinction as to whether it is right for men young or old to dance, but wishes to have common honors from all and to be extolled, setting no one apart. (204-209)

Against Amalek

Touch grass and worship Dionysos more

And for those of you who think Dionysian monasticism is a queer idea, well, these guys would beg to differ. There are as many ways to worship the Bacchic One as there are flowers in Nysa.

And the connection between Bacchic Orphism and Pythagoreanism isn’t exactly novel either; I’ve certainly written about it often enough, as have Gábor Betegh, Leonid Zhmud, Carl Kerényi, and a couple others.

Like Proklos:

All that Orpheus transmitted through secret discourses connected to the mysteries, Pythagoras learnt thoroughly when he completed the initiation at Libethra in Thrace, and Aglaophamos, the initiator, revealed to him the wisdom about the Gods that Orpheus acquired from his mother Kalliope.

And if you don’t think the community he founded was in any way monastic, might I recommend the Pythagorean Sourcebook? And reading, rather than talking shit in your “secret” Discord. I may have been gone awhile, but I’ve still got eyes everywhere. Silly thing; I don’t care that you hate me. I’ve seen what you cheer for. I didn’t think about you once during my hiatus. What a shame the same wasn’t true for you. Maybe you’d be happier if you touched grass and worshipped Dionysos more. It sickens you that I’ve returned? Well, it sickens me that you would say such vile things about Jews in space dedicated to He Who Loves the Stranger … and nobody challenged you. I will.

Prolegomena to Bacchic Judaica

Statue of Dionysus of Beth Shean
Roman period, 2nd century CE
Marble
H: 124; W: 61 cm
Israel Antiquities Authority
1990-821

And here are an assortment of academic articles:

Altar to Dionysus with an inscription in Greek Beth Shean Roman period, 141–142 CE Limestone H: 84; W: 40; D: 68 cm Israel Antiquities Authority 1991-2104

the Archer God

Against Karkûm

Against Kapaneus

Against Çorabaş

Against Abaddōn

Against Torpor

Against Šezbeth

Against Ṣemotat

Against Ponēros II

Against Dēvs

Against Guta